The longer I've gone on the more I've noticed that Boyd Rice calling punk nothing more than a fad is ostensibly a true posit that is hard to argue with. As much as I personally love the genre, it was seemingly contrived from the start and now the bands play on the very cruise ships which are supposedly so detested by these bands and so called 'alternative' artists. One can blame or chalk it all up to said establishment incorporated as grifting culture vultures stealing it or whathaveyou about uppity classes taking it from the lower...
whatever. money talks and bullshit walks.
The Ramones may precede the Sex Pistols in formation, but it is they (the latter) who enshrined this ideal of punk into the world with Johnny Rotten having the aspired attitude and Sid Vicious dressed up by Vivienne Westwood being the image of it all. That said and good an album as Never Mind The Bollocks is, the Sex Pistols were a boy band contrived by Malcolm McLaren; John Lydon being the only one (with the slight exception of original bassist Glen Matlock, though he rejoined the band once it regrouped for its reunions and still plays with them to this day) having his own entity beyond the band. Sure, it and the aesthetic terrorist movement it existed within was its own counter to the prior generation's counterculture of the hippies. Even then it's not so simply this genuine form of transgressive existence as those flower-power-make-love-not-war-peace-and-love-inc. may have been injected into the world given allegation of the Haight Ashbury clinic distributing LSD itself may have been a CIA operation. How then is one counter to the culture when they become the culture and merely play into it anyway? How does one go against the system by playing to its rules?
"Ugly words on the printed page no more constitute an act of transgression than happy platitudes painted on a protest placard constitute realities of any sort. They are empty and meaningless. Genuine acts of transgression are equally meaningless, though some might constitute criminality. Advocates of transgression seldom make the transition from word to deed, except in the context of the arts.[...]"More often than not, acts of transgression in the world lead not to liberation, but rather imprisonment. In a land and at a time where no amount of hyperbole, exaggeration, or overstatement can constitute even a thought crime, real acts are still punishable by law. But very few proponents of transgression resort to real actions, when words alone can create controversy or garner attention."—Boyd Rice, NO
Most everyone seems to think they're some underdog championing against this overarching power that controls the mainstream with their infinite power, it's rather interesting.
"Abortion is murder"
"My body my choice" "Trans people out of sports"
"Trans women are women"
"No Kings" "Don't tread on me"
"Come and take them"
"One nation under God" "God hates fags"
"From the river to the sea"
"Antisemitism" "Love is love"
And with that I'll offer one better: "Everyone keeps talking and they can't shut the fuck up," as Green Day sings in their song Lazy Bones. Now I happen to think Green Day is great in spite of all I've said here in regards to punk and its origins and aftermath— they're my favorite band of all time— but even in this I've noticed this shortsighted lacking perspective that goes along with many fans of the group in regards to this idea of the American Idiot; neglecting fundamentally that everyone under that national banner is included. As frontman Billie Joe Armstrong succinctly expressed while creating the title track in the documentary filmed of the albums concocting, being released nearly a decade after the matter and called Heart Like A Hand Grenade, that he himself is the American Idiot and as much when pointing a finger there's still three more aimed back at oneself.
With all this though I'm reminded of something that Charles Manson spoke of in the documentary Charles Manson Superstar, stating that if one is displeased with trees being cut down then stop buying the products like paper and pants produced by the deforestation; constrict what is disdained. And sure, even he may have been some sort of psyop himself, though while there is some credibility to the claim it's dubious at best. And he's not the only one who would be seen as consistent in living this ideal: figures like Ted Kaczynski, Varg Vikernes or John Brown are exemplary in such and embody a more absolute form of this Ghandi platitude of being the change wished to be seen rather than being merely all talk with a goodguy badge; as can be seen with an example of more recent exposure with a protest against the installation of a data center in Salem, MA featured a guillotine as a prop where it's mere performance, however in contrast these same people are of a political bend that tends to preach revolutionary ideals whilst simultaneously detesting and deeming the chanting to, "hang Mike Pence" and those who entered into the US Capitol building on January 6, 2021 as 'terrorists' or more popularly, "insurrectionists." All this to really say, put up or shut the fuck up and in the words of Mindless Self Indulgence:
"You think you're saying something relevant as you connect the dotsYou never realized you have to get in line to suck a cockYou're telling me that fifty million screaming fans are never wrong?I'm telling you that fifty million screaming fans are fucking morons!"